• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

The Baseball Diamond

Helping Players and Parents With Youth Baseball Equipment and Baseball Hitting Tips

  • Home
  • About
  • Core Baseball Equipment
    • Bats
    • Gloves
    • Cleats
  • Baseball Training Equipment
  • Baseball Field Equipment
  • Baseball Apparel
  • Baseball Tips
  • Shop Bats
    • BBCOR
    • Coach Pitch
    • Youth
    • Wood

Best Shoeless Joe First Base Mitt Options For 2025

by jeff Leave a Comment

The Shoeless Joe first base mitt is a fair example of what differentiates the brand from its competitors.

Many brands trump its latest styles and designs. But the gloves from Shoeless Joe tend to revel in its faithfulness to traditional styling for gloves and mitts.

It’s the reason why their brand comes from one of baseball’s legendary figures from almost a century ago.

But that doesn’t mean that Shoeless Joe rejects modern innovation in glove technology.

It’s true that some of their models evoke the styling of yesteryear, which has proven to work over the years.

But they also have their Professional series of gloves and mitts that were produced through classic methods as well as through new techniques.

Let’s take a look at some of their more popular offerings:

Shoeless Joe 1200FBR 12 inch First Base Mitt

Shoeless Joe First Base Mitt
Shoeless Joe First Base Mitt
Preform at the highest level, dig low throws out of the dirt, or make that wide at first catch with your Shoeless Joe Gloves First Base Mitt.
$196.99 Amazon Prime
Buy on Amazon

Last update on 2025-05-20 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

This is the 12-inch model made with 100% steerhide leather which has been finished with the traditional tobacco tanning profess that Shoeless Joe developed over the years.

The old time ingredients used for softening the leather are all rubbed in by hand, and it’s also been individually cut and sewn by hand.

The way the mitt has been prepared makes it look already game-worn, which is actially a good thing for leather products.

Break-in time and Protection

It doesn’t take long to break it in properly so that it molds with the shape of your hand perfectly.

But it also features the modern XRD foam, which offers deep impact protection.

It makes the mitt more durable, and it also protects your hand from pain and injury when you’re catching hard-thrown baseballs from the other fielders.

Webbing, Pocket, and Performance

This features a single-bar web along with a deep pocket so you can secure various types of throws. The open back also lets your wrist move more freely.

You’ll be better able to deal with wide throws that you have to reach out for, as well as low throws that you have to dig up.

Pros

  • It’s durable.
  • It doesn’t take long to break in.
  • It’s great for catching throws and fielding the position.
  • Your hand is well-protected.
  • The price isn’t all that high.

Cons

  • You still have to break it in.
  • The 12-inch size may be too small for some adult players.

Shoeless Joe 12 Inch First Base Glove

Shoeless Joe 13 inch Tennessee Trapper First Base Mitt

Sale
Shoeless Joe Tennesse Trapper 1st Base Glove
Shoeless Joe Tennesse Trapper 1st Base Glove
Shoeless Joe Ball gloves 13-Inch First Base Mitt Tennessee Trapper Professional Series is excellent for your teenage to adult first baseman.
$179.99 −$26.23 $153.76
Buy on Amazon

Last update on 2025-05-20 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

If the 12-inch model is a bit too small for you then this may suffice.

But its size isn’t just the sole reason why you ought to get it if you play first base.

It also has all the features you’d expect in Shoeless Joe gloves and mitts.

Like many of these gloves, the Shoeless Joe Professional Series 1300fbtt First Base Mitt has been individually cut and sewn by hand.

It uses the specially aged antique tobacco steerhide leather, with classic ingredients rubbed into the leather to make it feel softer.

Because of the handcrafting involved in the manufacture, you get a unique glove when you buy this mitt.

It’s also partially broken in, which accounts for why it already looks and feels as if it’s been used in games.

This means it doesn’t need as much time to break it in properly. It will mold nicely with your hand soon enough.

This is also features a more advanced design.

It doesn’t just have a deep pocket and an open back for flexibility, but it also features the special Tennessee Trapocket Web.

This web design is meant to help you catch various types of throws more effectively, and it also secures the baseball into the glove more firmly.

It’s a modern type of web that somehow combines nicely with the classic overall design of a Shoeless Joe mitt.

Pros

  • The price is still reasonable.
  • It offers a new type of webbing that helps in securing throws to 1st base.
  • It doesn’t take as long to break in.
  • The open back is comfy and offers flexibility.

Cons

  • It’s not for smaller players.
  • You may need to get used to the webbing.

Shoeless Joe 13 Inch First Base Mitt

Video: Shoeless Joe 1949 Golden Era edition Baseball Glove In Action!

https://youtu.be/D8RABO1mljE

13-Inch Pro Select First Base Tennessee Trap Baseball Glove

Shoeless Joe 13-Inch Pro Select First Base Glove
Shoeless Joe 13-Inch Pro Select First Base Glove
The Pro Select Series is designed for the baseball player that plays a significant number of games each season and has a personal goal of playing at the highest level possible.
$249.95
Buy on Amazon

Last update on 2025-05-20 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

This is more expensive than the other two, but that’s because it features the best attributes of the other mitts.

It also has the Tennessee Trapocket Web Design that helps secure your catches, and you also get the XRD extreme impact protection padding system that keeps you from getting hurt catching all those throws.

Once more it’s entirely made by hand, and it doesn’t contain any synthetic materials either.

It’s made entirely of steerhide. It also comes with cowhide inner lining that makes it more comfortable for you to wear.

This glove has the Pro Select leather laces that make it even stronger and more durable.

It even has a 2-tone look that some people may like.

Pros

  • It protects your hand very well.
  • The mitt is designed to last for a long time.
  • It’s comfy to use.
  • It looks especially nice.
  • It can hold your catches firmly in the mitt.

Cons

  • This may be too big for some younger players.
  • It may take a while for you to break it in.

Shoeless Joe First Base Mitt

Shoeless Joe Glove FAQs:

Q: Are Shoeless Joe gloves good for youth players?
A: Some models like the 12-inch 1200FBR are ideal for younger players, thanks to their lighter weight and quick break-in time.

Q: How long does it take to break in a Shoeless Joe first base mitt?
A: Most come partially broken in, so expect only a few sessions of catch to get them game-ready.

Q: What’s the difference between the Tennessee Trapper and regular first base mitts?
A: The Trapocket web is designed for extra grip and control on tough throws.

Final Words on These Shoeless Joe First Base Mitt Options

There are good reasons why Shoeless Joe gloves and mitts are so highly regarded by players and coaches.

Each of these gloves is unique, and they’re designed to fit and mold to the exact shape of your hand.

They can offer modern features that improve your play, yet the makers use proven traditional handcrafting methods to make sure that each glove is made with proper care and precision.

The customer service reputation of Shoeless Joe is excellent as well. In fact, when your glove becomes a bit too worn, you can send them to Shoeless Joe to be reconditioned.

Shoeless Joe First Base GloveThey will then treat it with the brands classic tobacco tanning material so that when it comes back to you it will feel and look like new again.

If you’re playing first base, you can’t skimp on the quality of your mitt.

You’re the last line of defense keeping hitters from reaching base. With the Shoeless Joe youth first base mitt, you can dig up and catch hurriedly thrown baseballs, and also field them yourself.

It’s long-lasting and effective, and it’s a terrific brand to consider.

Try the Pro Select First Base Tennessee Trap Baseball Glove if you have the budget, as it’s very comfy, quite durable, and extremely effective.

You can always check out other baseball gloves but I’m quite sure you’ll be pleased with a Shoeless Joe first base mitt.

Whether you’re a coach looking for a reliable mitt for your players or a serious first baseman yourself, Shoeless Joe has something for every level.

👉 Click any of the links above to check prices and read reviews on Amazon—your next favorite glove might be one click away.

Related Posts

  • Shoeless Joe Gloves - Take Your Game to the Next Level

    Shoeless Joe Gloves are known for their distinct appearance. It's not just for aesthetics as…

  • 2018 Axe Elite BBCOR Baseball Bat With Military Grade Alloy

    The Axe brand for baseball bats seemed to have become popular almost overnight, but that's…

  • 2018 Louisville Slugger Prime 918 BBCOR – Most Balanced Bat?

    Lots of players are looking forward to using the new 2018 Louisville Slugger Prime 918…

Filed Under: Gloves

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

2025 Baseball Bat Buying Guide

Easy guide to helping you know exactly which type of bat is required in your league!

Top 10 Best BBCOR Bats
Best Baseball Gloves
Best Baseball Bags
Top 5 USA Bats 2025
Nokona Baseball Gloves
2025 Best Metal Baseball Cleats

Socialize

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Recent Posts

  • Understanding the Different Youth Baseball Leagues
  • 2025 DeMarini The Goods Review: All Versions Explained
  • 2025 Louisville Slugger Atlas BBCOR Bat: Features & Review
  • 2025 Louisville Slugger Select PWR BBCOR Baseball Bat Review
  • 2025 Rawlings Icon Bat Review: Everything You Need to Know

Not What You Were Looking For?

Type your search phrase below:

Categories

  • Baseball Apparel
  • Baseball Field Equipment
  • Baseball Protective Gear
  • Baseball Short Stories
  • Baseball Tips
  • Baseball Training Equipment
  • Bats
  • Cleats
  • Core Baseball Equipment
  • Gloves
  • Uncategorized

Recent Comments

  • jeff on 5 Victus Bats You Must Consider For Your Baseball Arsenal
  • jeff on Why Akadema Baseball Glove Reviews Are Glowing in their Praise
  • Edward Casey on Why Akadema Baseball Glove Reviews Are Glowing in their Praise
  • Robert Holmes on 5 Victus Bats You Must Consider For Your Baseball Arsenal
  • jeff on 2025 List of the 10 Best BBCOR Bats

Need Help Finding Gear?

[email protected]

Disclosure

The Baseball Diamond is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com and affiliated sites.

Other affiliate programs may also be represented.

© 2025 · Privacy Policy · External Links Policy