• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

The Baseball Diamond

Helping Players and Parents With Youth Baseball Equipment and Baseball Hitting Tips

  • Home
  • About
  • Core Baseball Equipment
    • Bats
    • Gloves
    • Cleats
  • Baseball Training Equipment
  • Baseball Field Equipment
  • Baseball Apparel
  • Baseball Tips
  • Shop Bats
    • BBCOR
    • Coach Pitch
    • Youth
    • Wood

All Star CM3000SBT Catchers Mitt Review – For Serious Players?

by jeff Leave a Comment

All Star CM3000SBTThe All Star CM3000SBT is one of the most in demand mitts today. If you look at its ratings online, this is one product that has caught the attention and approval of baseball aficionados.

But just how good is this really, when compared with others sold online?

Popularity of course, does not always entail quality and reliability, which is why we decided to take a closer look at the All Star and see if it really lives up to the hype.

All-Star - Pro Elite CM3000SBT Catcher's Mitt
All-Star - Pro Elite CM3000SBT Catcher's Mitt
The most iconic mitt in professional baseball. This is the exact mitt worn by many pros. Forms a great pocket with a loud pop pitchers love.
$399.95
Buy on Amazon

Last update on 2026-11-22 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Features of the All Star CM3000SBT

All Star Catchers Mitt CM3000SBTOne of the key features of the All Star Cm3000 is its Japanese tanned steer hide.

Even if you’re not an expert on the leather used in catchers’ mitts, the texture and pattern on the mitt is clearly different from others.

But the difference isn’t just a matter of appearance as it also contributes to the longevity of the mitt.

It’s hard to emphasize the importance of the leather used in mitts. To put it simply this is what will determine if the mitt will last a long time or if it’s good for just one season.

The Japanese tanned hide used on the All Star is simply better compared to those used on other mitts.

The back of the All Star catchers glove CM3000SBT is smoothly designed, with the locking tab firmly in place and reducing the bulk.

Furthermore, this feature increases comfort and stability while making adjustments easy.

A common complaint among mitts is once you’ve put them on, it’s very difficult to adjust, but the All Star makes the process simple.

https://youtu.be/y5Rwjm92sk4

  • Read Consumer Reports & Reviews Here

Performance of the All Star CM3000

All Star Catchers Mitt CM3000SBT

in the picture: All Star Catchers Mitt

Before we go to the performance we need to check the break in. Conventional thinking says baseball mitts and gloves need to be broken in before you can use it.

The All Star also requires breaking in, but it’s much faster and easier. It’s stiff yes, but not to the point that it’s no longer flexible, and you don’t need to oil or microwave the mitt.

The bottom line: you’ll need to break it in but it won’t take too much time.

The mitt is handcrafted, and this has a positive effect when you use it.

For instance, the leather pocket is soft and gives you a better feel for the ball and for pitchers it comes with that pop that’s so hard to find in other gloves.

Once you’ve used the mitt frequently, you’ll notice that there’s plenty of support for ball handling. Normally these are things pitchers and catchers take for granted, but if it’s missing you’ll immediately notice it.

What Do Reviewers Say About This All Star Catchers Glove

As many reviewers have noted the mitt looks and feels durable, and once you’ve broken in it should work fine.

If you go online and read reviews you’ll see that this is built for intense use, but it’s light enough for use in a game of catch.

Here the soft, tan leather really comes into play as it adds a layer of flexibility that isn’t present anywhere.

When it comes to mitts there are a lot of factors to consider such as control, comfort, support, reliability and stability.

In all these major categories, the All Star company lives up and delivers. It’s more effective in some areas compared to others, but overall the mitts deliver during the game.

As any catcher will tell you, the best way to tell if the mitt is doing its job is if you can’t tell that it’s there.

Meaning, you should be able to focus on your game and not worry about how the glove fits. If you don’t notice the glove while you play, then it’s good.

On the other hand if you’re constantly making adjustments you will need to look for another mitt.

During our tests the All Star handled very well and didn’t require any adjustments. After a few games, it felt natural and didn’t cause any problems handling the ball.

The leather doesn’t just feel good, but it’s of the right thickness.

One more thing: the mitt smells great: it’s just how a good baseball mitt should smell like, and this adds to the feeling of authenticity.

https://youtu.be/-S61s2SWUuA

  • Read Consumer Reports & Reviews Here

Pros

The Cm3000sbt has many things in its favor:

  • The mitt is soft and large
  • Even with constant use, the mitt doesn’t get out of shape
  • Durable
  • The mitt is quite light in spite of the size
  • Made of high quality leather

Cons

While the All Star catchers mitt Cm3000sbt has a lot of notable features, it’s not without issues, although these are minor ones.

  • Sometimes the laces stretch out too much
  • You need to break in the glove

What Customers are Saying About the All Star Catchers Mitt CM3000SBT

Feedback for the mitt has been mostly positive:

James of Michigan:

  • “This is a very durable glove, and it’s beautifully designed too. I’ve been using this for a while and have had no problems with it.

Albert of Chicago:

  • The mitt is easy to break in, it’s light and the ball doesn’t pop out. I highly recommended this.

Tony of Atlanta:

  • I bought this for my son who plays baseball in college, and he’s very happy with it. He plays the game a lot and worn out more than his share of mitts, but the All Star is holding up just fine.

Dennis of Cincinnati:

  • I’ve been using this mitt for several months and it’s been great!

These are just some of the reviews about the All Star that you’ll see posted online, and the general consensus is that it’s a good mitt and you can depend on it for the long haul.

One of the more common issues with low quality mitts is they can only take so much force from the pitcher’s ball.

Here though that won’t be a problem as it’s been shown the All Star can withstand up to 80 mph pitches.

Conclusion For The All Star CM3000SBT

This is one of those products that deserve the title All Star catchers glove: it is made of high quality leather, it’s durable and does exactly what it should: protect your hand and make the game easier to play.

No, the mitt isn’t perfect as has been noted above, but whatever shortcomings it might have are overshadowed by the benefits.

Bottom line: This is one of the best high-end catchers mitts you can buy. It’s very durable and will last several seasons.

Looking For The Elite Series Version of The All Star Catchers Glove?

All-Star Pro Elite Catchers Baseball Gloves Cm3000bk
All-Star Pro Elite Catchers Baseball Gloves Cm3000bk
Extended life Smooth back design with locking tab eliminates bulk, improves comfort, and allows easy adjustment Leather backing is stiffer and gives the mitt just the right amount of support.
$399.95
Buy on Amazon

Last update on 2026-11-22 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Related Posts

  • Wilson A2K Catchers Mitt Review – Longest Lasting in Baseball?

    In this Wilson A2K catchers mitt review we'll find out if it's the longest lasting.…

  • Snag a Regent Baseball Glove When on a Budget

    Have you ever heard of these gloves before? You're about to because this page is…

  • Spalding Baseball Gloves - Too Cheap to Compete Today?

    There are so many great brands for hardball mitts and another one of those is…

Filed Under: Gloves

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

2026 Baseball Bat Buying Guide

Easy guide to helping you know exactly which type of bat is required in your league!

Top 10 Best BBCOR Bats
Best Baseball Gloves
Best Baseball Bags
Top 5 USA Bats 2025
Nokona Baseball Gloves
2025 Best Metal Baseball Cleats

Socialize

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Recent Posts

  • 2027 Louisville Slugger Select PWR BBCOR Baseball Bat Review
  • 2027 Louisville Slugger Atlas 2.0 BBCOR Baseball Bat Review
  • 2027 Rawlings Icon BBCOR Baseball Bat Review
  • 2027 Easton Hype Fire BBCOR Baseball Bat Review
  • Best Baseball Batting Tees (2026 Guide for Players & Coaches)

Best Selling Bats

Easton 2027 Hype Fire USA Baseball Bat | -10 | 30' | Lightweight feel for faster swings Easton 2027 Hype Fire USA Baseball Bat... $349.99
Louisville Slugger 2027 Supra™ (-10) USA Baseball Bat - 30' / 20 oz Louisville Slugger 2027 Supra™ (-10) USA... $349.95
Louisville Slugger 2027 Select PWR™ (-3) BBCOR Baseball Bat - 33.5'/30.5 oz Louisville Slugger 2027 Select PWR™ (-3) BBCOR... $399.95

Last update on 2026-11-22 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Best Selling Gloves

Wilson 2027 A2000® PF88SS 11.25” Infield Baseball Glove - Right Hand Throw, Blonde/Red/Sky Blue Wilson 2027 A2000® PF88SS 11.25” Infield... $329.95
Rawlings | Heart of the Hide Series Nolan Arenado Gameday Pattern Baseball Glove | 12' | Right Hand Throw | Navy/Scarlet Rawlings | Heart of the Hide Series Nolan Arenado... $329.99
Nokona WB-1200H Walnut Baseball Glove 12 inch (Right Hand Throw) Nokona WB-1200H Walnut Baseball Glove 12 inch... $399.95

Last update on 2026-11-22 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Categories

  • Baseball Apparel
  • Baseball Field Equipment
  • Baseball Protective Gear
  • Baseball Short Stories
  • Baseball Tips
  • Baseball Training Equipment
  • Bats
  • Cleats
  • Core Baseball Equipment
  • Gloves
  • Uncategorized

Recent Comments

  • jeff on 5 Victus Bats You Must Consider For Your Baseball Arsenal
  • jeff on Why Akadema Baseball Glove Reviews Are Glowing in their Praise
  • Edward Casey on Why Akadema Baseball Glove Reviews Are Glowing in their Praise
  • Robert Holmes on 5 Victus Bats You Must Consider For Your Baseball Arsenal
  • jeff on 2026 List of the 10 Best BBCOR Bats

Need Help Finding Gear?

[email protected]

Disclosure

The Baseball Diamond is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com and affiliated sites.

Other affiliate programs may also be represented.

© 2026 · Privacy Policy · External Links Policy